Act As An Automobile Mechanic
Original Prompt
Need somebody with expertise on automobiles regarding troubleshooting solutions like; diagnosing problems/errors present both visually & within engine parts in order to figure out what's causing them (like lack of oil or power issues) & suggest required replacements while recording down details such fuel consumption type etc., First inquiry – “Car won't start although battery is full charged”
Prompt Analysis
The original prompt calls for an automobile mechanic's expertise to troubleshoot car problems, with a specific focus on diagnosing engine and visual errors. It also mentions recording various vehicle details, such as fuel consumption. The first issue to be solved is a car that won’t start, despite a fully charged battery.
Strengths:
- Clear Role Definition: The prompt establishes the need for expertise in automotive troubleshooting, immediately signaling that the conversation will revolve around vehicle issues.
- Diagnostic Focus: It directs the chatbot to diagnose both visual and engine problems, ensuring a comprehensive analysis.
- Action-Oriented: The request to suggest required replacements ensures that the chatbot isn't just diagnosing problems but also providing actionable solutions.
- First Inquiry Introduction: The example issue— "car won't start although battery is fully charged"—gives a specific starting point for the chatbot to begin problem-solving.
Weaknesses:
- Ambiguity: While the prompt indicates that the mechanic should record details such as fuel consumption, it does not clarify whether these details are hypothetical or actual values provided by the user.
- Vague Scope: The term “errors present visually” is unclear. Does this refer to dashboard warning lights, physical damages, or something else?
- Limited Guidance for Responses: The prompt lacks details on how to format or structure the troubleshooting suggestions, which may result in overly technical or hard-to-follow explanations.
- No Mention of User Input: The user might have additional observations (e.g., sounds the car makes or recent repairs). The prompt does not indicate that the chatbot should ask follow-up questions for clarity.
Suggestions for Improvement
- Clarify Visual Diagnoses: Specify what “visual” errors refer to, such as dashboard warnings, smoke, or physical damage.
- Encourage Follow-up Questions: The prompt should encourage the chatbot to ask for more information, such as the sound of the engine or recent maintenance history, to better diagnose the problem.
- Structured Output: Request that the chatbot format its responses clearly, such as using bullet points or sections (e.g., "Potential Causes," "Required Replacements," etc.).
- Emphasize User Interaction: Guide the chatbot to request input from the user at each step for a more personalized diagnostic process.
Enhanced Prompt Example:
I need an automobile expert to troubleshoot car issues, specifically diagnosing both engine and visual problems (e.g., dashboard warning lights, physical damage, smoke). The expert should suggest possible causes and necessary replacements, providing a step-by-step explanation for easy understanding. Please also ask me follow-up questions to clarify the issue. For this inquiry, my car won’t start even though the battery is fully charged. I’d also like to log relevant information like fuel consumption type and recent repairs.
How to Continue the Conversation
After using this prompt, the user can continue the conversation with the chatbot by providing additional context or answering the chatbot’s follow-up questions. Here’s how they could guide the conversation:
- Provide More Symptoms: “The car is making a clicking sound when I try to start it. Could that be related to the starter or alternator?”
- Ask for Detailed Explanations: “Can you explain how I can check the fuel pump myself?”
- Request Specific Part Suggestions: “If the alternator is faulty, what brand or model of alternator would you recommend for my car?”
- Log Additional Information: “The last time I refueled, I used regular gasoline. Does that affect anything?”